From Courtroom Observer to Pete Rose’s Lawyer

From Courtroom Observer to Pete Rose’s Lawyer

When pitcairn become a teenager, his father had to testify at a tax evasion trial of mayfield avenue mob member peter “tito” carinci, and brought his son along to have a look at. The law-abiding robert pitcairn sr. Had not anything to do with the cleveland crime syndicate that become operating in newport, ky., but he had written a non-public test to cover a pal’s gambling debt at the glenn inn. Carinci occurred to be the resort’s supervisor. That check to assist out a chum landed pitcairn sr. A subpoena to testify at the gangster’s trial, which the more youthful pitcairn watched with exceptional hobby. “i notion it turned into charming, something i’d revel in doing. I used to be clearly thinking about it—it become only a exceptional revel in,” he recollects. After this primary glimpse of trial law, pitcairn turned into hooked. He attended the university of wooster in ohio for his bachelor’s degree, then earned his law diploma at the college of cincinnati in 1973. He's now a business litigator at katz, teller, brant & hild. “bob is recognized as one of the top enterprise litigators in our vicinity,” says grant s. Cowan of frost brown todd, who were given to understand pitcairn as opposing recommend at an ordeal 10 years in the past and developed a wholesome feel of appreciate for his opponent. “he is extremely cozy in a court and is at the pinnacle of his recreation at some point of move-exam, specially of hard witnesses.” mark j. Jahnke, president and ceo of pitcairn’s company, has labored facet-by means of-facet with pitcairn for more than 25 years. Some attorneys with pitcairn’s level of experience and professional fulfillment might “round corners,” jahnke says. “bob does not ever spherical those corners. He doesn’t do some thing 1/2-manner.” even on the subject of his hobbies, together with wine-amassing and driving motorcycles, he says, pitcairn “isn't always a dabbler. He very well researches and becomes very informed approximately them. He immerses himself.” take motorcycles. Pitcairn has been using them considering the fact that excessive school, starting out with a small honda. (“you meet the nicest human beings on a honda,” he says, quoting the old marketing campaign slogan.) now he owns a harley-davidson and a antique bmw, and rides them to work at his downtown cincinnati office whilst the climate allows. Or take wine. Pitcairn continues a set in his wine cellar, on the whole red bordeaux sorts, and he and his wife journey to winemaking regions on holidays. Maximum recently, in 2008, they visited stellenbosch, south africa, about 30 miles east of cape town. Pitcairn is a “legal professional’s legal professional,” says jahnke. “the variety of instances bob gets retained by lawyers or regulation firms is outstanding. And that’s approximately the biggest endorsement you could get.” well-known namesake born and raised in pittsburgh, pitcairn is associated with his nineteenth-century namesake, the scottish-american railroad government. “we call him r. P.,” says pitcairn. “he became the primary cousin of my wonderful-amazing-grandfather, william pitcairn. He was pretty a person.” the railroad govt became a lifelong friend of andrew carnegie and ran the pittsburgh division of the pennsylvania railroad in the course of a lot of the late19th century. In the course of his tenure, he ordered the development of a rail backyard alongside turtle creek near pittsburgh that might turn out to be the biggest rail backyard within the global. “i think, however am no longer sure, that my father turned into named after him. R. P. Died in 1909, and my father was born in 1922,” pitcairn says. Pitcairn sr.’s marketplace-studies process added his circle of relatives to cincinnati in 1966. “my dad desired to be a attorney, but his training became interrupted with the aid of world struggle ii,” says pitcairn. He thinks his father continually regretted now not becoming an attorney. As a young attorney, pitcairn settled in cincinnati along with his high school sweetheart, marian. The couple lately celebrated their 40th wedding ceremony anniversary with the aid of visiting san francisco and on foot throughout the golden gate bridge. Collectively, they raised two youngsters. Their daughter, jessica, is a fancy dress designer in the big apple metropolis; son, alex, is an aspiring actor in chicago. At age 62, pitcairn has been practising law for 37 years and counting, nearly completely specializing in business and business litigation. He has been sole or lead trial counsel in masses of civil proceedings, which include antitrust, civil rights, patent, probate, merchandise liability, securities and tax cases. James b. Helmer jr. Of helmer, martins, rice & popham, has acknowledged pitcairn for most of his career. “i do not forget him a pupil of the regulation, a formidable adversary, and a faithful best friend,” helmer says. “however it isn't his skillability and success as a trial lawyer this is his most significant asset. As a substitute it's miles the reality that he always obtains the quality possible end result for his clients. He stays at the pinnacle of his craft.” pitcairn’s most famous consumer became possibly pete rose. Rapidly after becoming a member of the reds as a participant in 1963, rose hired one of the founders of katz, teller, brant & hild, reuven j. Katz, to symbolize him. Pitcairn became a part of rose’s legal crew in the 1980s while rose pleaded guilty to filing fraudulent tax returns. Pitcairn represented rose whilst essential league baseball started out investigating the hit king in 1989 over gambling accusations. Baseball commissioner a. Bartlett giamatti got involved with plea offers, writing to a sentencing judge to vouch for the credibility of the witnesses lined up against rose. Rose and his legal professionals argued that giamatti, who acted as baseball’s “choose” in such matters, had prejudged the case. “we were arguing that pete hadn’t gotten a danger at due method,” pitcairn says. Decide norbert nadel issued a preliminary injunction stopping the league from banning rose, but giamatti effectively fought to get the case moved to federal courtroom, after which he and rose entered settlement negotiations. Because of the ones, rose voluntarily widespread everlasting ineligibility from most important league baseball. “from a attorney’s angle, the case with commissioner giamatti become charming,” pitcairn says. “it became surely an fantastic experience. I remember going domestic each night time and my answering machine became full. There have been newshounds hanging out at the fire escapes of our buildings. You analyze loads approximately the media, what they’re inquisitive about and why. We wound up having a quite desirable dating with them.” pitcairn once more determined himself within the realm of excessive-stakes professional sports when he represented the cincinnati bengals from 2003 to 2007. The hamilton county board of county commissioners sued the group, the country wide football league and its 31 other teams, claiming the defendants violated federal antitrust laws through using a monopoly over expert football to obtain a heavily subsidized lease for the bengals’ new football-handiest stadium. Ultimately, pitcairn received the case due to the statute of limitations. The county waited too lengthy to file suit, and the judge observed in prefer of the defendants, as upheld by using the 6th u. S. Circuit court of appeals, which, pitcairn says, is an exciting examine even for nonlegal sorts. One segment reads: “this case offers the trendy twist in the dating among the town of cincinnati and professional soccer, a courting that spans 86 years and at least 3 stadiums—the 0. 33 of that's the challenge of this controversy.” pitcairn also represented the property of austin e. “dutch” knowlton, a wealthy businessman who died in 2003, and whose property protected a 30 percentage ownership inside the cincinnati bengals. In his will, knowlton bequeathed his percentage to the charitable austin e. Knowlton foundation inc. Knowlton’s kids contested, accusing knowlton’s longtime attorney and depended on adviser charles d. Lindberg of having “undue impact” over him in addition to a battle of interest. Lindberg become co-executor of knowlton’s property and a minority shareholder of the bengals. His company—taft stettinius & hollister—represents the bengals. Pitcairn determined the case exciting to strive because of the high stakes and “larger-than-lifestyles” humans involved. Trial attorney stan chesley represented knowlton’s kids. With so many expert witnesses on each facet, it became “one of the most thoroughly litigated instances i’ve ever tried,” he says. In the end, pitcairn prevailed—the courtroom observed no conflict of hobby and knowlton’s desires have been carried out. “charlie lindberg is someone of the utmost integrity, and his actions regarding mr. Knowlton were absolutely vindicated with the aid of the jury,” pitcairn says. Lindberg calls pitcairn the satisfactory trial attorney in ohio. “[he’s] right away aware of the twists and turns of the trial complaints, conducts pass-examination with thoroughness however without personal hostility, in no way makes himself the problem in a case, and is aware and applies the highest ethical requirements to his practice.” in addition to his regular trial paintings, numerous years in the past pitcairn served as chair of the volunteer attorneys for the bad foundation, which offers criminal services to low-profits citizens, connecting indigent clients with private lawyers. The corporation become released by way of the cincinnati bar association and the criminal aid society of more cincinnati. “i found it quite profitable,” he says. “i saw how crucial the prison useful resource society is for a number of folks who can’t find the money for illustration. I’d like to do greater [community service] as my career starts offevolved to wind down.” not that winding down is synonymous with getting bored. “you constantly preserve learning—every case provides challenges,” says pitcairn. “that’s one of the nicest elements of what i do. It never gets stale.”